Another trip to Symphony Center in Chicago has raised another series of thoughts for the blogosphere... One of the great advantages of live concerts for me is the opportunity to listen to music I wouldn't normally turn on for myself:
Last night's program featured three works: Debussy's Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun, Esa-Pekka Salonen's new Violin Concerto, performed by Leila Josefowicz, and Sibelius's Symphony No.2.
I'll start with Salonen's work, since it is the inspiration for my title, and most musicological thoughts today. Henry Cowell, among others, strove toward the creation of an international, or global, music - one that would not be defined by nationalist labels. Often, I think, these nationalist labels are the result of the melodic content, with a supporting role played by the harmonies. Other techniques play a role too, of course, and have for centuries (Mannheim Rockets for example). However, what happens today in contemporary art music? So often, and Salonen's violin concerto is an example, we get music that is infused with feelings and moods, but lacks any tunefulness. Tonality is stripped away in favour of atmosphere. My question then is this: has globalization of art music created this atuneful atonality, or is it a conscious effort on the part of the composer to be more global in their art?
The rest of what follows are my comments on the performance itself...
As for the concerto itself, I found it interesting... it certainly showcased the virtuosity of Josefowicz, and had enjoyable moments. But, for me (as noted in other entries something of a conservative purist and idealist when it comes to musical taste), these moments weren't enough to hold together a 30+ minute piece. The second movement was, perhaps, my favourite, and was very quick.... over almost before realizing it had begun. The fourth movement was, for me, too long and didn't balance the overall for well enough. So much emphasis in the program notes was put on the "surprising" last chord... really, it felt like a 21st-century Picardy Third - not so shocking, just a happy twist to an ambiguous movement. Now, 8 gongs on the stage at once... that was interesting to me - but also, really why would you need 8 gongs for a symphonic movement, if not only for atmosphere and effect.
As for the rest of the program... I really enjoyed hearing Debussy's Prelude by an orchestra known for its big, brassy "American" sound. It was a great opportunity for the CSO to showcase their sensitive side. The problem then lies in an audience that may be too accustomed to the in-your-face CSO, and thus making a little more noise than I'd like. Really, paper rustling and cough-drop wrappers during the opening flute-solo don't add to the night!
Sibelius certainly knew how to end a symphony, and the audience responded very well to the work. Like Salonen, Sibelius also worked with the mosaic frame - a bunch of small ideas that connect together into a larger work. In the second movement, the blending of the basses and cellos as their parts weaved in and out of each other was fantastic. I felt that this movement really highlighted the definition of the orchestra as one instrument. It was nice to hear the trio of the scherzo movement as a feature for the woodwinds - as they often were, but aren't so often anymore.
Salonen's conducting was entertaining as an audience member. During the Debussy, I could imagine him dancing the ballet version of the work, although he seemed a little too smooth and fluid to really take Nijinsky's role (not that he should). Unlike Leonard Slatkin (from the last program I attended), it really felt like Salonen was leading the orchestra - not only in his own composition - but throughout. Sometimes, less dynamic conductors give the feeling that the orchestra is on auto-pilot, but not Salonen and not tonight. Occasionally, we went a little over the top for my liking -- too much movement from the conductor can distract from the performance (as can the baton hitting his stand), but overall, very enjoyable, with a great program.
Here, I will endeavour to record some of my musicological thinking that doesn't make it to the class room and term papers (along with some that does)...
Showing posts with label music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label music. Show all posts
Sunday, February 27, 2011
Monday, January 31, 2011
Laws of Art/Music: Discovery or Creation?
A quick thought that occurred to me last week, and I've been meaning to write about. Is it possible to discover laws of artistic endeavours, or are they created?
In reading about Russian modernism, and particularly the suprematist movement led by Kasimir Malevich, there was a suggestion that Malevich and his associates were trying to discover the laws that govern art. In discovering laws, are they not actually creating them?
As every first-year music student knows, there are laws about part-writing. Yet, are these truly laws that were discovered? I say no. They are laws that were created and modeled after the style of J.S. Bach. It was a group of people, over time, who entered these laws into the canon, not some act of discovery.
Howard Becker writes on this theme in Art Worlds... isn't it interesting though how the search for artistic laws become quests of discovery rather than creation - as though some universality might have been discovered in Malevich's work?
In reading about Russian modernism, and particularly the suprematist movement led by Kasimir Malevich, there was a suggestion that Malevich and his associates were trying to discover the laws that govern art. In discovering laws, are they not actually creating them?
As every first-year music student knows, there are laws about part-writing. Yet, are these truly laws that were discovered? I say no. They are laws that were created and modeled after the style of J.S. Bach. It was a group of people, over time, who entered these laws into the canon, not some act of discovery.
Howard Becker writes on this theme in Art Worlds... isn't it interesting though how the search for artistic laws become quests of discovery rather than creation - as though some universality might have been discovered in Malevich's work?
Kasimir Malevich, Suprematism 1916
Sunday, January 23, 2011
Symphony Hall
I love live concerts. I just got back from a night with the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, and it reaffirmed my love for live symphony music. From arrival at the hall to departure, I enjoy the experience. Usually, I include the ride to and from Symphony Center in my enjoyment: people watching on the trains can be very interesting. Tonight, a little less so. Nothing terribly exciting or entertaining happened, with the exception of a gaggle of sorority girls who got on at Addison and off at Sheridan... Don't people walk anywhere anymore?
Before the concert, as the players gradually arrive on stage and warm-up is in many ways my favourite part of the evening. Attending to specific instruments as they warm up, instruments that you might not normally focus on... Listening for little glimpses of the melodies that will return throughout the evening... watching the players interact, tell jokes, check out the audience... Then, the lights brighten on stage, and wane over the house.
I love the pomp and circumstance that reminds me of a gentler time. One where standing as someone enters is a sign of respect - not snobbery, just respect. The concertmaster, who sometimes seems almost embarrassed that all the attention is now on him (tonight was one of the assistant concertmasters, I guess Robert Chen had the night off). And the tune-up... largely not a necessity, and yet, a large number of players do make adjustments. Very few in the woodwinds, who largely play a single note or in octaves; more adjustments in the brass as they check multiple valves and tubing combinations; more again among the strings, and the sound of the lowered string being tightened into tune... ahhh.... Then the conductor...
One of the greatest joys of a major orchestra like the CSO is in the fact that over 5-6 concerts, you're likely to see 4-5 conductors. This season, we will have seen Maestro Muti twice, all others are guest conductors. From young up-and-comers, to established war horses, there is an excitement in seeing which brand of conducting will arrive on stage. Tonight, Leonard Slatkin brought a largely understated, albeit bouncy brand - one that always seemed to anticipate the orchestra, often by more than a beat... On the whole, I felt Slatkin just seemed out of sync with the orchestra... as for the closet conductors in the audience (myself often included) that is something different. Tonight, there was a particularly active "armchair conductor" in one of the boxes that make up the second floor of Orchestra Hall, very eagerly directing Bartok's Concerto for Orchestra.
Speaking briefly of the program, I found it rare, and wonderful, that the program featured all 20th-century works (granted, one was the first decade, and two from the 40s... but still). Elgar, Stravinsky, Bartok... As the concert hall is largely a museum of music - in which you get to sample only the smallest gallery in each visit, it was nice to see a night where the gallery featured works of a more recent vintage, and I could not help to notice that the musical depictions of the war and post-war years continue to bear much relevance to today's grotesqueries...
If you're in the area, and have the chance, go see the CSO. They are consistently considered among North America's best orchestras (often touted as the best), and among the best in the world. The brass section is to die for, especially if seat N3 on the main floor has anything to say about it!
http://www.cso.org
Before the concert, as the players gradually arrive on stage and warm-up is in many ways my favourite part of the evening. Attending to specific instruments as they warm up, instruments that you might not normally focus on... Listening for little glimpses of the melodies that will return throughout the evening... watching the players interact, tell jokes, check out the audience... Then, the lights brighten on stage, and wane over the house.
I love the pomp and circumstance that reminds me of a gentler time. One where standing as someone enters is a sign of respect - not snobbery, just respect. The concertmaster, who sometimes seems almost embarrassed that all the attention is now on him (tonight was one of the assistant concertmasters, I guess Robert Chen had the night off). And the tune-up... largely not a necessity, and yet, a large number of players do make adjustments. Very few in the woodwinds, who largely play a single note or in octaves; more adjustments in the brass as they check multiple valves and tubing combinations; more again among the strings, and the sound of the lowered string being tightened into tune... ahhh.... Then the conductor...
One of the greatest joys of a major orchestra like the CSO is in the fact that over 5-6 concerts, you're likely to see 4-5 conductors. This season, we will have seen Maestro Muti twice, all others are guest conductors. From young up-and-comers, to established war horses, there is an excitement in seeing which brand of conducting will arrive on stage. Tonight, Leonard Slatkin brought a largely understated, albeit bouncy brand - one that always seemed to anticipate the orchestra, often by more than a beat... On the whole, I felt Slatkin just seemed out of sync with the orchestra... as for the closet conductors in the audience (myself often included) that is something different. Tonight, there was a particularly active "armchair conductor" in one of the boxes that make up the second floor of Orchestra Hall, very eagerly directing Bartok's Concerto for Orchestra.
Speaking briefly of the program, I found it rare, and wonderful, that the program featured all 20th-century works (granted, one was the first decade, and two from the 40s... but still). Elgar, Stravinsky, Bartok... As the concert hall is largely a museum of music - in which you get to sample only the smallest gallery in each visit, it was nice to see a night where the gallery featured works of a more recent vintage, and I could not help to notice that the musical depictions of the war and post-war years continue to bear much relevance to today's grotesqueries...
If you're in the area, and have the chance, go see the CSO. They are consistently considered among North America's best orchestras (often touted as the best), and among the best in the world. The brass section is to die for, especially if seat N3 on the main floor has anything to say about it!
http://www.cso.org
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


